USA high court reviews Trump's power to block Muslim immigrants

Share
USA high court reviews Trump's power to block Muslim immigrants

In weighing the constitutionality of President Donald Trump's travel ban in highly-anticipated oral arguments Wednesday morning, the Supreme Court Justices returned repeatedly to the question of whether Trump's executive order trampled on Congress' right to set immigration policy. We hope the Court makes the right decision - that the ban violates the U.S. Constitution's command against religious discrimination.

The court is also looking at whether the ban is aimed at excluding Muslims from the United States.

This case was originally filed in the federal District Court for the District of Hawai'i in February 2017, and at first concerned the litigation about the second travel ban.

But the order was imposed by a man who falsely claimed that thousands of Arabs cheered in New Jersey when the World Trade Center collapsed; who demanded "a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States"; who declared that "Islam hates us"; who floated notions of closing mosques and cataloguing Muslim Americans; and who frequently has told an apocryphal tale of fighting Muslims by dipping bullets in pigs' blood.

The Trump Administration says the policy is needed for security, but challengers say the ban really targets Muslims.

The hearing was the culmination of a 15-month battle over a policy that quickly became a hallmark of the Trump era. It was met with nation-wide protests and was eventually blocked by the courts.

The supreme court likely won't issue a ruling on the case for at least a couple of months, but on Wednesday, the justices peppered the lawyers on opposing sides with a series of hypothetical situations that distilled the gnarly debate into simple yes-or-no questions. But, he maintains, the travel ban is illegal and unconstitutional and the President can not operate as though he is above the law.

Chief Justice Roberts wanted to know whether Mr. Trump was forever disabled from issuing orders concerning immigration.

Wednesday's arguments were the first time the justices had considered any of the bans in their entirety. The So-called Version 3.0 in September was open-ended and changed the countries.

Immigration attorneys and visa applicants from countries covered have complained about the scarcity of waivers granted and the lack of transparency around a process intended for applicants with serious medical needs or significant personal and business ties to the United States.

Sen. Hirono and Texas GOP Senator Ted Cruz successfully petitioned the Supreme Court to release an audio recording and transcript of the oral arguments immediately after the arguments concluded.

However, in December, the Supreme Court ruled that the third ban could go into effect while legal challenges were being heard.

The result is an nearly complete cutoff of travellers from the named countries.

But the Washington, D.C., lawyer for Hawaii and the other challengers to the Trump order, Neal K. Katyal, asserted that the President has directly contracted what Congress had decreed and is attempting to seize unilateral power to take "a wrecking ball" to any immigration law at will.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg to Francisco: "You mentioned 1182 (f)".

Justice Samuel Alito asked the question again, presenting a less detailed scenario in which "the threat of the infiltration of the United States by terrorists was so severe with respect to a particular country" that the measures passed by Congress are inadequate.

The travel ban is the first Trump policy to undergo a full-blown Supreme Court review.

"The exclusion of aliens is a political act", he said. "That's for the courts to do, not the president?"

While on the campaign trail, Trump advocated for a full Muslim ban.

"If you look at what was done, it does not look like a Muslim ban", he said.

The current version of the travel ban emerged from a "multi-agency review" and a recommendation from the president's Cabinet, he said. It included Iran, Yemen, Somalia, Libya, and Syria and added Chad, another predominantly Muslim country.

Francisco said that if that a President were told by members of his staff and his Cabinet that "there is honestly a national-security risk here and you have to act"-that is, act to keep all Israelis out of America-"I think then that the President would be allowed to follow that advice, even if in his private heart of hearts he also harbored animus".

MR. KATYAL: Justice Alito, I think if it were just the list, I think we'd be right - you'd be right, although I'd point out that you, yourself, in the Stormans case said that it's a religious - it raises an inference of religious gerrymander, of "the burden imposed falls nearly exclusively on those with religious objections".

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Boston Celtics blow great opportunity in Milwaukee
Now - just as much as Kyrie Irving and Gordon Hayward - the "Jay-Team" holds the keys to the next great Boston basketball team. The Bucks led by 20 points with 7:37 remaining in the third quarter before the Celtics got back in the game with a torrid run.

Tyronn Lue Reacts to LeBron's Epic Buzzer-Beater in Game 5
Cleveland entered the postseason giving up 109.9 points per game and have held IN to 96.8 per contest through four games. James first blocked Victor Oladipo's go-ahead layup attempt to keep the game tied at 95 with three seconds left.

Bayern are better than last season warns Real's Zidane
Only Louis van Gaal, with Barcelona and Bayern, and Carlo Ancelotti, at Real Madrid , had managed double figures. We're very motivated: winning it three times in a row is something unique.

Not even the Jets can screw up this NFL Draft | Politi
BC-FBN-Draft-Patriots Preview, 803 Usually reserved Patriots to be busy in this year's draftAP Photo NY151Eds: With AP Photos. The Cardinals have the No. 15 overall pick in the first round and could go a number of different ways with the selection.

Officer who arrested Toronto van attack suspect commended for actions
Those in the typically bustling neighbourhood where the attack took place said they were struggling to make sense of the violence. "You will always be loved and your love for sports will always be with me while I cheer with you", he wrote on Facebook .

Gmail's Big Redesign Is Rolling Out Now. Here's What to Look For
You can choose to have the email "expire", or become inaccessible, in one day, one week, one month, three months or five years. One of the big changes is the new confidential mode meant for making it easier to send sensitive information via email.

This Time About North Korea
She said her husband has given more than 1,000 speeches and has done everything he could to help bring the victims back. Kim made his only known travel outside North Korea since becoming leader to meet with Xi in Beijing in March.

Facebook's rise in profits, users shows resilience after scandals
Facebook said monthly active users in the first quarter rose to 2.2 billion, up 13 percent from a year earlier. Daily active users reached 1.45 billion, also an increase of 13 percent over the same time previous year .

Amazon now delivers to your auto trunk in Tampa Bay
If you do not now have an active connected service plan, just push the blue OnStar button inside your vehicle to activate service. When an Amazon delivery driver needs to drop off a package, they can connect to your lock via Amazon's cloud to unlock the door.

Brow Beaten: Pelicans sweep Trail Blazers behind Davis, Holiday
But if the postseason is where players really earn their money, then the Pelicans' Holiday spending could very well be worth it. Coach Terry Stotts said there will be "no limitations" on Turner, although they will have to monitor his pain tolerance.

© 2015 Stocks News Daily. All Rights reserved.