Supreme Court divided over partisan districting

Share
Supreme Court divided over partisan districting

Gerrymandering is nearly as old as the republic; it derives its name from Elbridge Gerry, a 19th-century MA governor who approved a redistricting that included a misshaped state Senate district that resembled a salamander.

Wisconsin is being sued over politically gerrymandered legislative districts, and the case is just days from the Supreme Court.

Throughout the session, the justices and lawyers alike appeared to cast their questions and remarks with the hope of attracting Kennedy. Kennedy asked Wisconsin's solicitor general, implying that extreme partisan gerrymandering could violate the right to free speech by preventing those in the minority-in this case Wisconsin Democrats denied representation-from having an equal say in the political process.

Though the court sidelined the political gerrymandering question in Vieth, Kennedy wrote separately that he would be open to hearing a future challenge if someone could develop a workable test.

If the Supreme Court sets guidelines to prohibit partisanship from being used to draw district lines, it would put "10 to 12 more chambers in immediate play" in six or seven states, said Jessica Post, the executive director of the Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee.

It should be said that this three-part test is only one of many one might use to determine whether a states redistricting plan violates the equal protection clause.

The case pertains directly to Wisconsin but could affect OH and other states.

Kennedy then asked if standing were established whether the redrawn electoral maps be unconstitutional. Their ruling, due by June, could have an impact on US elections for decades by setting standards for when electoral districts are laid out with such extreme partisan aims that they deprive voters of their constitutional rights.

In Gill v. Whitford, Democrats found a favorable three-judge district court, but a five-vote majority of the Supreme Court blocked the ruling from taking effect while the court considers the case.

It would be unreasonable to let voters in a different state challenge Wisconsin's congressional map, he said, and allowing voters in a single state legislative district to do the same for a statewide map would be just a problematic.

Republicans returned to the Capitol last January with a 64-35 seat majority in the state Assembly and a 20-13 advantage in the Senate.

Representative Dan Kildee (D-Michigan), said, "This has been done by democratic legislatures in the past as well, it doesn't make it right". After the new maps were passed, Republicans won 60 of the 99 seats in the state Assembly in the 2012 election, despite the fact that they carried only 47 percent of the vote.

They said Republicans packed Democrats into some districts and spread them out across others as a way to create more districts conductive to a GOP candidate. The girl's parents filed suit against the Garden City mayor and aldermen seeking damages for what they argued was negligence on the part of the city by allowing the bleachers to fall into a unsafe condition.

So the subtext of the discussion about the NLRB's position seems to me to be that even independent executive branch agencies change their minds when administrations change - a perhaps unremarkable observation except when the Supreme Court is considering how much credence it should place in an agency's legal reasoning.

"We will have to decide in every case whether the Democrats or the Republicans win", Roberts said.

Courts have struck down districts as racially biased for decades, and other partisan districting lawsuits are moving through the courts in Pennsylvania, Maryland and North Carolina.

The Supreme Court's decision would likely come next year. Now that Justice Neil Gorsuch has joined the court he will presumably break a tie.

"Politicians are never going to fix gerrymandering". Do they dramatically benefit one party over the other?

He pressed the state's lawyers about whether it would be unconstitutional for the state to simply declare that it was going to favor one party over another.

Walter Shaub, former head of the Office of Government Ethics, echoed this sentiment, concluding,"Make no mistake about it: Extreme partisan gerrymandering is corruption". The Wisconsin map "was the most partisan" map possible. In their brief, they noted that thousands of individuals are held beyond six months, one year on average, and hundreds for more than two years. "What it protects is their right in the workplace to decide they want to get to the courthouse, but once they get to the courthouse..." he said before Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg cut him off.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Willie Snead set to return from suspension for Week 4 in London
They are now third in the AFC East and are coming off a disappointing loss to the New York Jets in their last outing. The Miami Dolphins will serve as the home team in their game against the New Orleans Saints in London on Sunday .

Harry Kane nets two more goals Spurs beat Huddersfield 4-0
Huddersfield managed just six shots in this game - only twice in its previous 107 league games had it attempted fewer in a match. Harry Winks made his first Premier League start since April on Saturday and barely looked as if he had been away.

Olivier Giroud has officially made Arsenal HISTORY after scoring in tonight's game
Rob Holding almost had his second goal for Arsenal from another corner but he swung at the ball and smashed his shot off the post. But Walcott opted against taking the spot kick, allowing Giroud to step up for what was his 100th goal for the North Londoners.

5 big announcements at Amazon's surprise hardware event
Recently, they announced a partnership with Microsoft which would allow Alexa and Cortana to share their abilities and skills. Available in blue and red colours, the buzzers can be connected to Amazon Echo and serve as inputs for Alexa-powered games.

Georgia's Nick Chubb has final word at Tennessee
Bob Shoop's group responded and forced a field goal, but it immediately turned the game in Georgia's favor. Bennett made the trip to Notre Dame to be Georgia's third quarterback when Eason was ruled out.

Bears, Packers each link arms during national anthem
Packers and Bears players, coaches and other staffers locked arms on the sidelines during the national anthem Thursday night. But even with a short-handed supporting cast, Rodgers showed the Bears the value of stability and confidence at quarterback.

Trump proposes his tax reform plan
Our commitment to those affected is this: We are with you , we will stay with you , and we will come back stronger than ever. Married couples get at least $20,800: $12,700 for the standard deduction and two personal exemptions of $4,050 each.

Seahawks Lose RB Chris Carson With Fracture In Left Leg
He needed to be carted off and have his leg placed in an air cast after being stood up by defenders and driven backwards. Seattle was down 15-10 at home in the third quarter to the Indianapolis Colts , a two-touchdown underdog.

Internationals battling at Presidents Cup
I'm hoping that I can redeem myself this week. "You start to kind of look forward and wonder where this momentum could take us". You dream of moments like this". "It was a disappointing result, but could've been worse", added Leishman.

Quick Yinzing: Steelers tame Ravens in rivalry win
Villanueva noticed the booing directed at Ravens players as they knelt together before the anthem in a silent prayer for America. Wide receiver Jeremy Maclin should play a bigger role. "You're not going to make a bunch of changes; you just have to improve".

© 2015 Stocks News Daily. All Rights reserved.